Charlotte Day Wilson: Alpha

Charlotte Day Wilson's "Alpha": Stellar Music, Subpar Vinyl

Charlotte Day Wilson's "Alpha" serves as her technical debut studio album, though the Toronto-based artist had previously established herself through several noteworthy EPs—Palimpsest (2012), CDW (2016), and Stone Woman (2018). Her earlier release "Work" from the CDW EP earned Wilson critical acclaim and introduced her distinctive voice to a wider audience.

Critical Recognition
With "Alpha," released through her independent label Stone Woman Music, Wilson solidified her artistic reputation, garnering multiple nominations at the 2022 Juno Awards including Songwriter of the Year, Producer of the Year, and Traditional R&B/Soul Recording of the Year. This recognition speaks to the exceptional craftsmanship evident throughout the album, creating substantial anticipation for her future projects.

Musical Excellence
Wilson's vocal performance on "Alpha" channels a spiritual power reminiscent of legends like Dusty Springfield and Nina Simone. While her approach embraces more contemporary and experimental production elements, the foundational elements of her artistry—emotive delivery, thoughtful lyrics, and impeccable vocal control—connect her to these iconic predecessors.

The album showcases Wilson's comprehensive talents as a vocalist, songwriter, and producer, presenting a cohesive artistic vision that balances modern R&B production with timeless soul sensibilities. The instrumentation provides a rich, varied backdrop that perfectly complements her stunning vocals throughout the record.

The Vinyl Me, Please Pressing
Unfortunately, the Vinyl Me, Please edition of "Alpha" fails to match the quality of the music it contains. From a manufacturing perspective, this pressing exhibits numerous shortcomings—rough-edged vinyl, imprecise groove cutting, and packaging that feels hastily assembled rather than crafted with care.

Despite these physical drawbacks, the sonic presentation remains surprisingly acceptable, if inconsistent. Occasional pops and crackles intrude on the listening experience, though they tend to be intermittent rather than persistent. The dynamic range proves reasonable for an independently produced release, allowing Wilson's sophisticated arrangements to breathe adequately.

Value Assessment
At its current price point, the Vinyl Me, Please edition offers questionable value. Since it appears to be essentially the same pressing as the standard Stone Woman Music release (merely differentiated by colored vinyl), budget-conscious collectors would be better served by purchasing the original release from local record stores at a lower price point.

For those specifically attracted to colored vinyl variants, the VMP edition might still hold appeal. However, all potential buyers should temper their expectations regarding pressing quality regardless of which version they choose.

The Vinyl Verdict
Charlotte Day Wilson's "Alpha" showcases a remarkable musical talent whose songs deserve better vinyl treatment than either current pressing provides. The album itself remains highly recommended for fans of thoughtful, soulful R&B with contemporary production touches, even if the physical product falls short of audiophile standards.

Until a truly premium pressing becomes available, listeners can still enjoy Wilson's exceptional artistry through these existing editions—just be prepared to accept some manufacturing compromises along with the musical excellence. 💵

💰 Invest
💵 Consider
💸 Pass